Cattaraugus County, NY home prices

Cattaraugus County, NY: the typical home is worth $166,489 as of 2026-05, up +4.1% over the past year and +189.4% since 2000. Listings run about $122/sq…

Data as of May 2026 · by the Real Estate Price Map data team · methodology & sources

1986: $35,009 → 2026: $166,489 (4.8×) pre-2000 estimated via FHFA index

Market read

At $166,489, homes in Cattaraugus County sit 34% below the New York median ($252,432) and 29% below the US median ($233,954). That ranks #58 of 62 New York counties by price.

Prices are holding steady (+4.1% in the last year) — a balanced market.

Homes here take a while to sell — a median 64 days on the market, with 12% of listings cutting their asking price.

At 3.0× local income, that's more affordable than the typical US county (~3.8×).

Against the typical US price-to-income and price-to-rent, homes here look ~22% cheap for local incomes and rents — a relative bargain.

Buying looks cheaper than renting — ~$822/mo to buy (P&I, 20% down) vs $1,029/mo to rent.

Home value history

Zillow ZHVI, monthly from 2000 · recessions shaded. See the full 1975 history on the interactive map →

Nearby counties

McKean County, PA ($111,369) · Allegany County, NY ($139,646) · Erie County, NY ($297,430) · Chautauqua County, NY ($176,823) · Wyoming County, NY ($207,172) · Warren County, PA ($137,848)